Treadmills vs. Bikes vs. Elliptical vs. Rowing Machines Comparison : Which is best?

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Fitness is a hot topics these days. There’s a fair reason for this. We just want to feel and look safe. The easiest way to do so is by exercising and eating well. If you’re looking to get into shape, there are plenty of exercise machines to help you get there such as treadmills, bikes, elliptical machines and rowing machines.

If you’ve ever tried to look up elliptical exercise combo machines to get started with weight loss, you’ve probably been daunted and confused. There’s also a lot of confusion about which machine is best for you. If you’re not lucky enough to have access to all four machines, which should you choose? 

If you’re like me, you don’t have time to go to the gym or even go for a walk in the park. Exercise bikes, believe it or not, are an excellent option for anyone who lives in a small space.

Athletes have known for years that exercise is one of the best ways to burn calories, increase energy, and strengthen the heart. As many people struggle with a hectic schedule, exercise seems like a great way to escape the grind, but not everyone loves a good workout—and the treadmill has been designed to give you a heart-pumping workout without the intense physical exertion.

CrossFit athletes may argue that rowing machine are the best cardio because they engage multiple muscles and burn a large number of calories in just a few minutes.

A gym instructor could say the elliptical trainer is the very best because they are so safe, have a low injury risk, are extremely easy to utilize, and also gym participants appear to be attracted to them.

In this article, we take a look at each of these machine and compare them to one another in terms of cost, ease of use, benefits, and other criteria. While some of these machines may not be for everyone, they are all (theoretically) equally effective at burning calories and producing weight loss results.


The first thing you need to understand about treadmill running is that it is a high impact exercise. Unlike walking, where your body is suspended by the action of your legs, running puts you in a position of landing on the ground with every stride. By walking a treadmill, you can run without the stress to your hip and knee joints.

Treadmills are typically the most expensive piece of equipment in a fitness club, costing two to three times as much as a stationary bike or an elliptical and majority of high-end treadmills are constructed with running deck that help to soak up running influence and weight.

This is because a treadmill provides a great deal of flexibility in deciding on a physical activity. A treadmill can be used for running, jogging, walking or a few actions. It can be used while watching a TV program or on the radio.

If the room you have in your home is small, you would like to consider a small space treadmill. Running a stretcher is an excellent way to strengthen the cardiovascular system. You will burn fat and tone your muscles.

In addition to this, the treadmill enables you to train at a faster pace. This is important if you are trying to lose weight. Walking at a slower pace uses way more energy than walking at a faster pace.

A study from the University of Georgia shows that walking at a slower pace requires an expenditure of about 1.2 calories per minute, while running requires an expenditure of about 3.5 calories per minute.

Some treadmills also provide electronics features and set-ups that allow you to customize your workouts to meet your specific fitness requirements. Almost all versions consist of speed and incline and can be optimized for individual calorie-burning, rate and kilometric targets.

The most obvious reason for using a treadmill is the fact that it is the most common form of cardio equipment in gyms. Every gym on the market offers treadmills, making them very convenient. The second most obvious reason is the fact that running on a treadmill is a lot easier than it is outside. A third reason is the fact that treadmills are generally more stable and less likely to tip over than other cardio machines.

Before buying a treadmill

Treadmills at home, on the other hand, are not suitable for everyone. A good treadmill can cost from between $500 to over $5,000, depending on its quality. If you know you’ll use it often, it’s well worth the investment. When looking for a treadmill, keep the following in mind:

Go on a test run : join a gym for a month or visit a friend house to use a similar treadmill to make sure you like it.

Keep safety in mind. Make sure the treadmill has safety features like handrails and an automatic shut-off or an emergency stop button.

Consider your needs. Higher end treadmills come with more bells and whistles, but you may just need the basics. Some options include:

  • Built in televisions
  • Higher weight limit
  • Belt made from material that lessens the impact on your legs
  • Reduced noise
  • Fold-up ability, making for easy storage
  • A place to plug in your handheld MP3 player
  • Extended warranty


Treadmills are usually the most expensive exercise machines since they have a lot of advanced technologies, like a console that lets you change things such as the surface , speed, or incline.   

Considering these modern technologies are important to you, it is well worth paying slightly more for the machine that will let you monitor your training sessions entirely.  However, if you only want to exercise on a simple and easy machine, then you may choose to save a couple bucks and go for something cheaper, such as a rowing machine or bike.

All you have to do is figure out how much you can afford to pay for it and go for a machine that is within your price range.


When you buy a treadmill, portability is likely to be an important factor in your decision. Is it possible to fold the treadmill? Is there a series of wheels included in the package? Is it possible to assemble it using software? Both of these are important considerations before making a purchase.

However, there is another question you might have: Can I quickly move this thing around if necessary? Since the larger the machine is, the heavier it is (and the heavier it is, the more difficult it is to maneuver), yet the smaller the machine is, the less expensive it is (and the less expensive it is, the less likely the pieces of machinery can last – which means you’ll have to repair them sooner).

However, due to the limited space, he will be unable to purchase a treadmill, will be forced to install it in a less visible position, or may even be forced to purchase a foldable treadmill to fit the room. If the room is big enough, he will eventually buy and hold a treadmill.


Treadmills are by far the biggest machines in terms of total footprint. Treadmills are the largest type of machine and one of the longest. Their average dimensions are 65′′ x 45′′ x 22′′.

To fit a treadmill, you’ll need a lot of space, and you’ll also need to think about how you’ll get it in and out of your building, particularly if there are a lot of obstacles or narrow passageways.

Treadmills, on the other hand, are at a very low altitude. So, if you’re looking for a computer that will work in a garage or a room with low ceilings and plenty of floor space, they could be your best bet.

While some treadmills fold up for easy transport, they are usually the least maneuverable of the four devices we’ll be looking at. There are certainly better options if you’re going to be moving your equipment around a lot.


The treadmill is a simple aerobic machine with few features. While it is less difficult to use than a rower, there is still room for error and damage if you do not use it correctly. It’s not difficult to learn how to use a treadmill.

Unlike the more common alternatives of running outdoors or on the track, treadmills allow for more precise monitoring of your progress. For example, you can see how fast you are running, how many calories you’re burning, and the distance you’ve covered.

If you are planning to get your own treadmill and wondering what to learn first, you know that the list of treadmill exercises and workouts is endless. So what is the top treadmill learning tip for starting out right? Whether you get on a treadmill to lose weight, stay healthy, or simply to improve your fitness level, you should start slow. Choose a lower speed and gradually increase the speed as you become more comfortable. That way you will be more likely to stay on the treadmill longer, and you will not be tempted to jump right up to the fastest speed.

But if you want to get the most out of your treadmill workouts, make sure you properly warm up and cool down.

To warm up, start at a walking pace. At first glance, the various functions for speed control, incline, and resistance can appear overwhelming. However, many designs come with straightforward instructions and the basics of the system are clear. You take a step forward and walk/run forward while the belt spins under your feet.

Make sure the treadmill is at the correct speed for your walking or jogging pace. Starting at a faster speed may result in injury. The following video demonstrates how to use a treadmill for the first time:


Using a treadmill makes cardio exercises a lot easier. You can use them at home and don’t have to worry about the weather. In addition, you don’t have to worry about getting hit by a car or something else while running on a treadmill.

Exercises that require weight bearing, such as walking and running, engage more muscle mass than exercises that do not require weight bearing, such as cycling. If you’re trying to lose weight and have the option of exercising on a treadmill or a stationary bike, the treadmill will burn more calories. When done at the same intensity level, an individual in weight-bearing exercises can burn more calories, according to American Sports Medicine College.

The treadmill mostly benefits the lower body and the cardiovascular system. The main muscles affected are the upper legs (both hamstrings and quadriceps), calves, and glutes, which become more so as the incline on your treadmill increases.

Abdominals are often worked, particularly while running. The back, pecs, elbows, and arms are still used, but to a lesser extent. You can multitask, watch TV, read a magazine, and check email while exercising. Treadmills that are well-built reduce the impact on the joints. To step up fat burning, you can vary the speed and slope.

The treadmill could be a better option for you depending on your level of health, stamina, and willingness to endure punishing workouts, particularly if you’re trying to gradually increase your exercise program or avoid high-intensity exercise.

Several studies have shown that treadmills can be used for much longer periods of time than a high-intensity alternative such as a rowing machine.

According to an article published on ACE fitnesss, using a treadmill on a regular basis can help develop stamina / endurance, improve cardiovascular ability, and strengthen the durability of your leg / back muscles.


Treadmill injuries are not uncommon. Whether it’s a tumble on the treadmill while walking at a brisk pace or an awkward fall while running, injuries can be painful and a huge inconvenience. Health experts say that common treadmill injuries can be avoided if you take some precautionary measures.

Shock-absorbing treadmill provide a safe and more effective workout for runners than traditional running equipment. The running belt of a shock-absorbing treadmill is surrounded by a strong shock cord that stretches as the user’s foot hits the ground, so they literally bounce off the belt without ever actually touching it. This action reduces the impact on your joints and spine, minimizing risk of injury.

It can damage your hips, ankle joints, and knees has some validity. The risk of physical injury, however, is extremely low.

As per the Consumer Product Safety Commission, there would be an approximate 22,500 treadmill accidents in 2019, with 2,000 of those affecting kids under the age of eight. From 2018 to 2020, 17 deaths associated to the use of a treadmill were reported to the department.

Despite their fearsome reputation, treadmills are perfectly safe to use, and there is really no need to avoid them entirely. 

Quick Tips to be safe from unwanted treadmill accidents

Allow enough space for it. Leave a distance of at least two feet on either side of a treadmill and about six feet behind it to prevent crashing into a wall or to be wedged between the machine and a wall or furniture when the balance is lost.

Do remember to use the safety switch. Every treadmill comes with a safety key that you can attach to your clothing. If you do fall, the key will pull out and the belt will come to a complete stop. Instead of leaving it wrapped around the handrail or dangling down the foot, make use of it. If you need to take a break mid-workout, use the “stop” or “pause” buttons to bring the system to a halt. When you slip, the belt will be stopped. This prevents further damage such as burns of friction.

When you turn on the treadmill, straddle the belt. This prevents you from knocking your foot off.

Never get off a treadmill when it’s running. Let the belt stop before it disassembles.

Maintain an upright posture. When you look at your feet, you are more likely to lose control.

Keep the unit in good working condition. After each usage, lubricate as per the manufacturer’s instructions, secure any loose equipment (just using manual toolkits), and wipe away any sweat—especially on the hand grips and controls.


When you have a treadmill, you are going to need to ensure that it is in good working order. In order to do this, you should check that it is working properly at least once a month, but it is even better to do so before you go to use it. This will ensure that you don’t go to use it and it won’t work or worse, that you injure yourself because it has not been properly maintained.

To be sure, they’re also less complicated, since they’re mostly self-contained, and apart from sometimes inspecting all of the buttons on the console, there’s nothing else you need to do.

The only slight warning? Treadmills are very complicated devices with many moving parts. As a result, they are slightly more prone to going insane, and you may find yourself needing to call someone out to repair a flaw, which may influence your decision to obtain one. If the job is minor, you can do it yourself.

When you first get the treadmill, you should do a thorough check to make sure everything is working as it should. 

  • When the belt is not moving smoothly, you can replace the belt.
  • When the belt is ruined, you have to replace the entire belt.
  • When the deck is not moving smoothly, you can lubricate it.
  • When the deck is ruined, you have to purchase a new belt to fit the deck.

Exercise Bike

Related Articles

Leave a Comment